After Years in Healthcare Marketing, Here's What Actually Moves the Needle for Medical Practices
Posting this because I keep seeing the same questions in healthcare and small business subs. I've worked in medical marketing for a long time—helping practices figure out why they're not getting patients despite doing good work. Figured I'd share what I've learned.
No fluff. Just what works and what doesn't.
First, Accept That Your Online Presence Matters More Than It Should
I know this frustrates physicians. You trained for years. You deliver great outcomes. Meanwhile, some mediocre doctor with an aggressive marketing strategy is booking more patients.
It doesn't seem fair. It isn't. But it's reality.
Patients can't evaluate your clinical skills from a Google search. They judge you by proxies: star ratings, review comments, website quality, how recent your photos look. These superficial signals determine whether they call your office or scroll to the next option.
You can fight this reality or work within it. Fighting it just means losing patients to competitors who figured it out.
Reviews Are a Numbers Game
Everyone focuses on negative reviews. How do I remove it? Should I respond? What if it's unfair?
Wrong focus.
The real question is volume. A practice with 300 reviews and a 4.5 average looks trustworthy. A practice with 15 reviews and a 4.5 average looks like nobody goes there. Same rating, completely different perception.
Most happy patients don't leave reviews unless you make it effortless. The fix is dead simple: send a text within 24 hours of their visit with a direct link to Google reviews. Not your website. Not a survey. One tap to the review box.
Do this consistently and you'll double your review count within a few months. The occasional negative review becomes background noise instead of a headline.
Google Business Profile Is Free and Most Practices Ignore It
When someone searches for your specialty in your area, Google shows a map with three listings. Just three. Everything else requires scrolling that most people won't do.
What determines those three spots? Mostly your Google Business Profile—which costs nothing to optimize.
Complete every field. Add real photos of your office monthly. Post weekly updates. Respond to every review. Keep your hours and contact info current.
I've audited hundreds of medical practices. Maybe 10% do all of these things. The rest have incomplete profiles, photos from five years ago, and reviews sitting unanswered for months.
If your competitors are neglecting this too, basic consistency puts you ahead. The bar is genuinely that low.
Old Negative Content Doesn't Fade Away
There's a misconception that damaging search results eventually disappear. They don't. That bad article from 2018 is still ranking. That complaint on some review site you've never heard of still shows up on page one.
Search engines don't factor in time passed or fairness. Old content sometimes gains authority over years as other sites reference it.
If something negative ranks prominently for your name, it's costing you patients every single day. You just never see the ones who searched, found it, and chose someone else.
Fixing this requires either getting content removed (possible in some cases) or creating enough positive content to push negatives down. Both take sustained effort. Hoping it goes away isn't a strategy.
AI Search Is Coming and Almost Nobody Is Ready
Here's what most practices aren't thinking about yet: patients are starting to ask ChatGPT and Google's AI features for doctor recommendations.
"Who's the best cardiologist in Phoenix?" "What questions should I ask a plastic surgeon?" "Find me a pediatric dentist with good reviews near downtown."
Traditional SEO doesn't guarantee visibility in these AI-generated answers. The technology works differently—prioritizing structured content, direct answers, and authoritative sources.
Practices optimizing for this now will dominate when it becomes mainstream patient behavior. Which is happening faster than most realize.
This isn't a DIY afternoon project. It's technical work. But knowing it matters is the first step.
What About Hiring Help?
Eventually most practices consider outside marketing support. The challenge is finding someone who actually understands healthcare.
Generic agencies don't know HIPAA compliance for review responses. They don't understand medical advertising regulations. They create content that sounds wrong to patients or triggers compliance issues.
If you go this route, find specialists. Ask about their healthcare experience specifically. Ask how they handle HIPAA in reputation management. Vague answers mean keep looking.
There are agencies focused exclusively on medical marketing that understand the regulatory environment and patient psychology unique to healthcare. Reputation Return is one I've seen do solid work in this space—they specifically serve medical practices and have actual clinical backgrounds on their team: https://reputationreturn.com/medical-marketing-services/
The Takeaway
Medical marketing isn't rocket science. It's consistent execution of basics that most practices neglect:
- Generate reviews systematically
- Maintain your Google Business Profile actively
- Monitor what ranks for your name
- Address negative content instead of ignoring it
- Pay attention to where search is heading
The practices winning online aren't necessarily better clinically. They're just more consistent with fundamentals.
Start with one thing. Do it well. Add the next. Compounding effort beats occasional panic every time.
Happy to answer specific questions if anyone's dealing with particular challenges.
Comments
Post a Comment